Skip to content
Gulf South Engineering and Testing, Inc.
Menu

Guides

SPT Borings vs. Undisturbed Sampling: Choosing the Right Soil Samples

· Gulf South Engineering and Testing

By Gulf South Engineering and Testing

A soil boring is only as useful as the samples that come out of it. Two methods do most of the work on Gulf Coast sites: Standard Penetration Test (SPT) sampling with a split-barrel sampler, and thin-walled tube ("undisturbed") sampling. They answer different questions, and many investigations use both in the same boring.

What SPT sampling gives you

ASTM D1586/D1586M describes the SPT as driving a split-barrel sampler with a 140 lb hammer dropped 30 in. "to obtain a soil sample for identification purposes, and measure the resistance of the soil to penetration" (ASTM D1586/D1586M, section 1.1). The result is the blow count, or N-value.

The standard calls the SPT "the most frequently used subsurface exploration drilling test performed worldwide" and notes that it "provides samples for identification purposes and provides a measure of penetration resistance which can be used for geotechnical design purposes" (same source, section 4.1).

Good for: identifying and classifying soil layers, a penetration-resistance profile with depth, and sands and mixed soils where a thin tube does not work.

What undisturbed (thin-walled tube) sampling gives you

ASTM D1587/D1587M covers "using a thin-walled metal tube to recover intact soil samples suitable for laboratory tests of engineering properties, such as strength, compressibility, permeability, and density" (ASTM D1587/D1587M, section 1.1).

It has limits: the practice "is limited to fine-grained soils that can be penetrated by the thin-walled tube" and "is not recommended for sampling soils containing coarse sand, gravel, or larger size soil particles, cemented, or very hard soils" (same source, section 1.2).

Good for: soft and medium clays where settlement, consolidation or strength drive the design.

Side by side

SPT (split-barrel)Thin-walled tube
StandardASTM D1586/D1586MASTM D1587/D1587M
What you getSample for identification plus a blow count (N-value)Intact sample for engineering-property tests
SoilsMost soils, including sandsFine-grained soils the tube can penetrate
Typical useLayering, classification, penetration resistanceStrength, compressibility, permeability, density

Choose SPT sampling if

  • you need soil layers identified and classified down the boring
  • the site has sands or mixed soils
  • your engineer's design method uses N-values

Choose undisturbed sampling if

  • soft or medium clays are present and settlement or strength matters
  • your engineer needs laboratory strength or consolidation tests on intact specimens

Neither alone, if

  • the site has both clays and sands, which is common; your geotechnical engineer will usually plan both methods in the same boring and choose depths for each

Gulf South Engineering and Testing performs undisturbed and SPT sampling and shallow and deep soil borings up to 300 feet deep, with laboratory testing performed in accordance with ASTM and/or other approved procedures.

Frequently asked questions

What is an N-value?

The number of hammer blows needed to drive the SPT sampler over a set interval of a drive; ASTM D1586/D1586M defines it as the blows over the 0.5 to 1.5 ft depth interval of a 1.5 ft drive.

Why are tube samples called "undisturbed"?

The thin-walled tube is designed to recover intact soil for laboratory tests of engineering properties, as ASTM D1587/D1587M describes.

Can tube sampling be used in sand?

ASTM D1587/D1587M does not recommend it for soils containing coarse sand, gravel or larger particles; other samplers such as the split barrel are used there.

Who decides which sampling method to use?

Your geotechnical engineer, based on the site and the design questions the project needs answered.

Sources

All guides|Contact Gulf South